Commons Comics

Getting the Story Straight: Peter Bagge’s ‘Woman Rebel: The Margaret Sanger Story’

, , 2 Comments

16 Flares 16 Flares ×

If you’re not familiar with Peter Bagge, he’s best known for comics about suburban youth with titles like “Hate,” “Apocalypse Nerd” and “Everybody Is Stupid Except for Me.” Here’s a self-portrait that captures his damp, bug-eyed style as well as his chronically ironic tone:

bagge my little pony

(Image from reason.com)

If you’re not familiar with Margaret Sanger, trained as a nurse, she found her passion as a writer and birth-control activist in the early 20th century after she had treated countless poor urban mothers who, sick and exhausted, begged her to help them stop having children.

00v/49/arve/G1899/024

(Image from biography.com)

When I heard that Bagge’s most recent book was a biography of Margaret Sanger, Bagge could have illustrated my reaction pretty effectively: Huh??!!

bagge cover image

As Bagge explains in the afterword to this meticulously researched book, his main motivation for taking on a biography of Sanger was the contradictions in online accounts of her history. “She was an effective practitioner of civil disobedience and passive resistance” (74), he writes, yet type her name into a Google search, and most of what comes up calls her “a racist; a genocidal maniac; a member of the KKK; both a fascist and a communist (sometimes in the same sentence), and my favorite, the inventor of abortion” (75). Bagge did his own research into primary sources, putting Sanger’s quotes back into historical context and even digging up original versions of photos that now appear on the Web in doctored form.

But Bagge’s motivation wasn’t merely to set the record straight. Bagge explains that Sanger’s life was so long, complex and “literally action-packed that all I could think of was ‘comic book!’ whenever I read of her exploits” (75). Perhaps even more than the demonstrations, raids and arrests, however, Bagge was drawn by Sanger’s fiery spirit, which angered pretty much everyone at some point: enemies, family, friends and benefactors. And she spent a good deal of time fuming, too. Here’s a short visual history of Sanger’s standard reaction to insult, illogic and injustice:

bagge first fuming framebagge angry nurse one framebagge tiny radical one frame

Bagge’s version of Sanger’s story addresses a lot more complication and nuance than these frames convey, however. That middle frame, for instance, is her response after visiting the mother depicted below, who was on the verge of death the last time Sanger visited:

bagge tired mom

Not only does the doctor refuse on legal grounds to pass on any information—it wasn’t until the 1960s that the Supreme Court officially declared the Comstock Laws, which limited sales and “promotion” of contraceptives, unconstitutional—but he insults the woman in her ignorance, saying that she should send her husband to sleep on the roof if she wants to stop having children.

Sanger quickly tires of the self-righteousness and illogic of birth control gag rules. It was the post office at the time that determined what was too “indecent” to travel through U.S. mail, so when Sanger’s sex-ed column for the “New York Call” is censored, she revises the copy:

bagge what every girl should know

Sanger does, arguably, “win” in the long run by getting her information out, but Bagge doesn’t paper over the mistakes and uglier moments of her life history. Sanger’s belief that every woman deserves the right to make her own decisions about her reproduction drew her to every women’s group she could muster an audience from, including Ku Klux Klan members. Rather than shrinking from this controversial moment in Sanger’s history, Bagge illustrates in a single frame why Sanger agreed to speak to an audience whose views she found distasteful: one of the audience members raises her hand early in the talk to ask Sanger to clarify her “terminology,” which is no more complicated than the word “vagina.”

The KKK appearance combined with her attempts to bring birth control to African-American women in the South—at the behest of both Southern and Northern African-Americans, the most high-profile of whom was W.E.B. DuBois (depicted top left in the page below)—have made Sanger an excellent illustration of the way that misinformation can run rampant on the Web. Since I’m running out of room, here’s a newsletter article from New York University’s Margaret Sanger Papers Project that effectively untangles the truth from the controversy:

http://www.nyu.edu/projects/sanger/secure/newsletter/articles/bc_or_race_control.html

Bagge carefully details his sources and explains what didn’t fit into the main narrative in 18 pages of footnotes. He also does a fine job of condensing the complicated situation that led to the shutdown of Sanger’s Harlem clinic, and sparked her quest for a birth control pill:

bagge race and pill

But lest you shy away from this book thinking it’s all dense history and controversy, I assure you that it’s not only fascinating, but fun, especially when Bagge depicts Sanger with historical oddballs and luminaries like Havelock Ellis and H. G. Wells:

bagge ellis brain one frame bagge h g wells

Not only does Bagge illustrating Sanger’s life make perfect sense to me now, but I’m eager to see more of this genre of comics biography, and am looking forward to learning more about whatever historical figure he decides to take on next.

While Bagge’s biggest challenge was condensing Sanger’s life and vast accomplishments, Joe Sacco, whose most recent work I’ll review in my next post, decided to slow down and stretch his subject out—quite literally, into a 24-foot fold-out “panorama.” “The Great War” portrays, without words and in black and white, the first day of the bloody Battle of the Somme from World War I. It does not promise to be “fun,” so let’s hope the sun returns to Goshen by then. In the meantime, stock up on good books from

better-world-books-logo-goshen to keep you cozy, and see you in another two weeks.

16 Flares Facebook 10 Twitter 6 Google+ 0 Reddit 0 StumbleUpon 0 Pin It Share 0 Email -- 16 Flares ×
 

2 Responses

Leave a Reply

(*) Required, Your email will not be published